05/11/2014
Moving to Opportunity or Isolation? Network
Effects of a Slum Relocation Program in India
Sharon Barnhardt, Erica Field, and Rohini Pande
Working Papers
A" housing" lottery" in" a" large" Indian" city" provided" 110" out" of" 497" participants the"
opportunity" to" move" out" of" a" slum" and" into" improved" housing" on" the" citys" periphery."
Fourteen"years"after"housing"assignment,"relative" to"lottery"losers,"winners"report"better"
housing"conditions"farther"from"the"city"center,"but"no"change"in"family"income"or"human"
capital."Winners"also"state"increased"isolation" from" family"and"caste"networks"and"lower"
access" to" informal" insurance." In" particular," they" are" significantly" less" likely" to" know"
someone"they"can"rely"on"for"borrowing"needs"and"report"fewer"informal"transfers"in"the"
event" of" shocks." We" also" observe significant" program" exit:" 34%" of" winners" never" even"
moved" into" the" assigned" housing" and" 32%" eventually" exited" the" colony" to" be" closer" to"
family" and" the" city" center." Our" results" suggest" that" the" benefits" of" improved" suburban"
housing"were"offset"by"its"drawbacks"in"the"form"of"destruction"of"social"capital,"pointing"to"
the"importance"of"considering"social"networks"when"designing"housing"programs" for" the"
poor.