Faculty & Research

Research Productive

Show result

Search Query :
Area :
Search Query :
2757 items in total found

Working Papers | 2015

The Consumer Protection Bill, 2015: (Lack of) Rights of the Consumer to Terminate Sale Contract

Akhileshwar Pathak

Consumer protection law rests on the foundations of contract law and the law of sale of goods. A consumer law has to conceptually express this foundation and the modifications it is bringing about in these laws. Without this, the law would become unclear, conflicting and confusing. The Consumer Protection Bill, 2015 is not secured in its foundation and needs revision. The paper reviews the rights of the consumer to terminate the contract and makes suggestions for revision. The suggestions, with brief comments are as follows:

1. Unfair Contract Term

The bill declares an unfair contract term to be void. The sale of Goods Act, 1930 gives the right to a buyer to terminate a contract if the supplied goods do not meet the description, are not of merchantable quality or are not fit for the agreed purpose. Ousting of these by contract terms is a deprivation of a right created by the law. This is an unfair contract term and taken to be so in other jurisdictions. The bill should give effect to this by making the following addition:

Ousting of implied conditions and warranties void: The implied conditions and warranties created for the buyer in the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 cannot be limited or excluded by contract terms. A contract term ousting the implied conditions and warranties is void.

2. Rights of the buyer to terminate a sale contract

The rational and logical way of organising the law is to mention the rights of the consumer. A consumer could approach a consumer council for the redressal of the rights. The bill does not mention the rights of a consumer. Under the Sale of Goods Act, 1930, the buyer has certain rights to terminate the contract. The followings could be introduced on the rights of the buyer to terminate a contract:

Termination of contract for breach of quality of goods. A consumer has the right to terminate the contract on the grounds of quality of goods in the following situations:

(1) The seller delivers goods which do not meet any of the express conditions in the contract or implied conditions arising from the contract. The consumer can terminate the contract within 30 days of delivery. If the contract provides a longer period for terminating the contract, the consumer can terminate the contracted during the period mentioned in the contract.

(2) The seller delivers goods which do not meet any of the implied conditions created for the buyer in the Sale of Goods Act, 1930. The consumer can terminate the contract within 30 days of delivery.

(3) The buyer has a right to terminate the contract on the ground of the seller delivering goods which are in breach of express or implied condition but elects to get the goods repaired or replaced. Following this, the seller repairs or replaces the goods. The repaired or replaced goods continue to be in breach of an express or implied condition or need further repair and replacement. The consumer can terminate the contract within 10 days of the seller delivering the repaired goods or goods in replacement.

(4) The buyer does not have a right to terminate the contract but a right to repair or replacement. Following this, the seller repairs or replaces the goods. The supplied goods continue to need a repair or replacement.

Termination for delay in delivery: A consumer has the right to terminate the contract for a delay in delivery in the following situations:

(1) The contract provides for a delivery schedule. The delivery of goods on schedule is of essence to the contract and the seller fails to deliver the goods on schedule.

(2) The contract provides for a delivery schedule. The delivery of goods on schedule is not of essence to the contract and the seller fails to deliver the goods within a reasonable period of the schedule.

(3) The contract does not provide a delivery schedule. The seller fails to deliver the goods within a reasonable period after formation of the contract.

(4) The contract provides for a delivery schedule but the consumer agrees to an extension of the schedule. The seller fails to deliver within the extension period.

3. Powers of Consumer Council

A consumer can approach a Consumer Council for the enforcement of the rights. A Consumer Council should be generally vested with the powers to issue orders and directions to enforce the rights. The specific powers should include powers corresponding with the rights of the consumer. The following could be the powers of the Consumer Council on the rights of the consumer to terminate a contract.

Powers of Consumer Council: The Consumer Council can issue orders to the consumer, trader or an opposite party for the enforcement of the rights of the consumer. The orders can include one or a combination of the followings:

1. Order the parties that the contract is terminated.

2. Order the trader to return any money paid by the consumer with or without interest.

3. Order the consumer to return the goods to the trader.

4. Order the trader to restore any benefit or money equivalent of the benefit drawn from the consumer.

5. Order the consumer to restore any benefit or money equivalent of the benefit drawn from the trader.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

Dispersion in macroeconomic volatility between the core and periphery of the international trade network

Anindya S. Chakrabarti

At the country level, macroeconomic volatility tends to correlate with trade openness although the direction of correlation is not stable across samples. Here I consider trade networks as sum of all pairwise trade linkages to emphasize that different linkages contribute differently to the transmission or mitigation of shocks, and show that across the network volatility is inversely related to centrality, a summary measure of strength of the linkages specific to a country. I study a multi-country, multi-sector trade model
subject to idiosyncratic productivity and liquidity shocks, and characterize volatility as an explicit function of centrality, diversification and the Herfindahl of the trade network in equilibrium. With sufficient skewness in trade linkages across countries, similar shocks generate different levels of repercussions across the network. The conventional effect of diversification holds true that countries with better diversified portfolio fluctuate less compared. Centrality directly contributes to better aggregation of shocks. Combined effect of these two channels dominates the opposite effect that a more central country is also more exposed to shocks. The model calibrated to the E.U. generates and closely replicates the negative relationship between centrality and volatility. The
theoretical model is then extended to capture stochasticity and sparsity in the trade networks.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

Inflationary effects of monetary policies in newly industrialized economies with cross-sectoral labor and capital immobility

Anindya S. Chakrabarti

This paper studies the effects of monetary policies in newly industrialized economies characterized by extremely low level of labor and capital mobility between urban and rural sectors. Policies are executed in the urban sector
which sends waves of adjustments in the rest of the economy. I show that with liquidity constraints and immobility in labor and capital, the sector-
specific effects are markedly different from those in a one-sector economy. In particular, they are asymmetric and the rural sector lags behind the urban sector during the adjustment process. This explains temporary phases of significantly high inflaction with uneven sectoral effects which often accompany major reforms in the banking and monetary institutions of such economies,
e.g. in case of India. Finally, as the consumption patterns alter in such an economy undergoing structural changes, the sectoral distribution of liquidity is affected inducing dissimilar responses to shocks, both within and between sectors.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

Stochastic Lotka-Volterra equations: A model of lagged diffusion of technology in an interconnected world

Anindya S. Chakrabarti

We present a model of technological evolution due to interaction between multiple countries and the resultant effects on the corresponding
macro variables. The world consists of a set of economies where some countries are leaders and some are followers in the technology ladder. All of them potentially gains from technological breakthroughs. Applying the famous Lotka-Volterra equations to model the evolution of technology frontier, we show that the way technology diffuses creates
repercussions in the partner economies. This process captures the spill-over effects on major macro variables seen in the current highly globalized world due to trickle-down effects of technology.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

Economic incentives versus institutional frictions: migration dynamics within Europe

Anindya S. Chakrabarti and Aparna Dutta

The immobility puzzle in European Union takes the form that the observed level of migration
within Europe is substantially less than is expected in an union which allows free labor mobility, indicating that there are possibly institutional barriers inhibiting migration. In order to pin down the missing mass of migrants, we propose a theory of cross-region migration in a multi-region setting with heterogeneity in sectoral compositions, productivity and endowments of productive inputs. Migration arises as the result of adjustment process of workers in response to uneven region and sector-specific shocks in factor productivity. When tested on U.S. which we consider to be a benchmark for institutional homogeneity, this model explains substantial part of variability in both the nominal and the relative levels of state-to-state migration. However, for Europe, the model explains the relative
ow network well but predicts a higher nominal
ow than is seen in the data illustrating the puzzle. Following the hypothesis that heterogeneity across European countries in institutional factors induce a friction on such labor reallocation process driven by economic incentives, we use dyadic regression to analyze the effects of pair-wise institutional distances which broadly captures various types of socio-cultural and political differences between countries, on the missing mass of migrants. Linguistic differences appear to be an important factor explaining the gap.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

Consumer Rights in the New Economy: Amending the Consumer Protection Act, 1986

Akhileshwar Pathak

Liberalisation and globalisation of the India economy, inaugurated in 1990, ushered in a qualitatively different economy. In these decades, there has been expansion of goods and services; diversification in the means of reaching the consumer; proliferation of trade practices; coming in of e-commerce; vigorous sales promotion; and aggressive advertising. The persona of a consumer has undergone a transformation. The legislative regime for protection of consumer needs reform. The government has suggested changes in the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. Taking this as the context, the article reviews the proposed amendments and identifies further areas for amendment. The article has identified four overarching aspects of consumer rights for review, unfair terms in contracts; unfair trade practices; commerce through online platforms; and definition of consumer.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

Dynamic Pricing of Electricity: A Survey of Related Research

Goutam Dutta and Krishnendranath Mitra

In this paper, we survey 82 papers related to revenue management and dynamic pricing of electricity and lists future research avenues in this field. Dynamic pricing has the potential to modify electric load profiles by charging different prices at different demand levels and hence can act as an effective demand side management tool. There are different forms of dynamic prices that can be offered to different markets and customers. Forecasting of demand, and demand price relationship play an important role in determining prices and helps in scheduling load in dynamic pricing environments. Consumers' willingness-to-pay for electricity services is also necessary in setting price limits. Elasticity of demand is an indication of the demand response to changing prices. Market segmentation can enhance the effects of such pricing schemes. Appropriate scheduling of electrical load enhances the consumer response to dynamic tariffs.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

A Note on Estimating Variance of Finite Population Distribution Function

Sumanta Adhya, Tathagata Banerjee, and Gouranga Chattopadhyay

Estimating finite population distribution function is an important problem to the survey samplers since it summarizes almost all the relevant information of interest about the finite population. Moreover due to its nonlinearity estimation of variance of estimators of distribution function remains an active area of research since Chambers et al., 1992. Both analytic and resampling-based variance estimators are developed earlier. Here we poropse a bootstrap hybrid variance estimator of model-based semi-patametric estimator of finite population distribution function estimator. We prove its consistency and also show that its numerical performances are superior to analytical estimator.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

How Costly is the Deliberate Disinflation in India?
Estimating the Sacrifice Ratio

Ravindra H. Dholakia and Kadiyala Sri Virinchi

Methods followed in earlier studies for estimating the sacrifice ratio or the real cost of deliberate disinflation have focused only on aggregate supply side ignoring aggregate demand. The present study considers the adjustment path obtained as a locus of short run equilibria to arrive at a theoretically acceptable sacrifice ratio. The study uses quarterly data from the period between 1996-97Q1--2013-14Q4 in India and employs both the regression as well as the direct methods to estimate the ratio. The results have revealed a sacrifice ratio ranging from 1.7 to 3.8 depending on the method and the measure of inflation used. Such a magnitude of the real cost of disinflation in India, also relevant in the long run, clearly contradict the dominant view among policymakers that the trade-off, if any, is negligible. Deliberate disinflation policy needs to consider the real cost of sacrificing output and employment particularly when its magnitude is substantial.

Read More

Working Papers | 2015

Specialist Services in the Indian Rural Public Health System for Maternal and Child Healthcare – A Study of Four States

Shreekant Iyengar and Ravindra H. Dholakia

The present study attempts to examine the role of specialist services in rural public health system of India in the areas of maternal and child healthcare. The study uses primary data collected through a survey of doctors and paramedical staff working at public health facilities regarding availability and quality of the specialist services in gynaecology, paediatrics and anaesthesia. The study discusses in detail the aspects of infrastructure, manpower and operational challenges faced in effective provisioning of specialist services through the rural health facilities of four largest states-Bihar, Madhya Pradesh (MP), Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh (UP). The findings of the survey reveal significant dearth of specialist doctors with their concentration at the district level. Moreover, there are severe misallocations of the specialist doctors and, lack of manpower support, equipment and basic infrastructure within the public health system causing serious challenges in effective provisioning of specialist services for maternal and child healthcare. Lastly, the efforts made by the government for providing additional manpower support for these services are also not giving desired results.

Read More
IIMA